Leftover Halloween Candy Pie

Leftover Halloween Candy Pie – With 5 kids who all trick-or-treated for over 2 hours on Halloween, as you can imagine – we’ve got a ton of candy! I mean – 4 pillowcases full of Halloween candy, as well as (Victoria’s) Halloween plastic pumpkin! I hate to throw Halloween candy out because it’s such a waste, so what I’ve done throughout the years is donate 1/2 of the candy and then keep the other 1/2.

Leftover Halloween Candy Pie

Leftover Halloween Candy Pie - Recipe

This year (for some reason) the candy is like a bottomless pit! Every single time I think we’re going through it, another pile appears! I’ve never made Leftover Halloween Candy Pie, but this year – I’m going for it, otherwise I’m afraid the candy will be present in our house till the New Year! My friend Sheri shared this insanely delicious looking recipe with me and I’m thrilled to share it with you!

Leftover Halloween Candy Pie

Leftover Halloween Candy Pie

Ingredients for Leftover Halloween Candy Pie:

2 pre-made pie crusts

1 stick of butter (melted)

½ cup brown sugar

Leftover Halloween candy (yum yum!(


Coarse sea salt

How to Make Leftover Halloween Candy Pie:

  • Pre-heat oven to 350ºF

  • Place pie crusts on top of eachother and roll them with a rolling pin to make a rectangle.

Leftover Halloween Candy Pie

  • Place crusts on an ungreased baking sheet.

Leftover Halloween Candy Pie

  • Whisk together melted butter and brown sugar then spread on top of the crust.

Leftover Halloween Candy Pie

  • Chop up desired candy bars into pieces and top the pie crust.Leftover Halloween Candy Pie

  • Layer on some pretzels.

  • Leftover Halloween Candy Pie

    Bake for 25 minutes.

    Leftover Halloween Candy Pie

  • Remove from oven and sprinkle with some coarse sea salt while still warm.

Leftover Halloween Candy Pie

  • Let it cool 30 minutes before serving.

I mean – how amazing does this look? It’s every kid’s dream come true and beyond! Make sure you take the time to get some photos of your kids indulging! This only happens once a year! So embrace it!

Check out another Halloween Recipe fave of mine here!

Leftover Halloween Pie

Thank you to Sheri McShane for this amazing recipe and idea! *Sheri McShane is a contributor for MomGenerations.com! Sheri has the blog: When the Kids Go to Bed.

Hello All. My name is Sheri. I am a working mother of 3 pretty darn fabulous little boys. I’m trying very hard to handle the stresses of working, being a mother, being a wife, keeping house, and finding the time to just laugh and enjoy life. A few things you should know about me: I’m an iced-coffee addict, I love to organize, and I love my wine. I am also a master at fort-building and being the belly-eating monster. Fitness and healthy eating habits are important to me so you may hear a little about that too. Here you will read about my daily musings and of course my venting, wine glass in hand. Hope you find something you can relate to. Cheers. If you’re a crafty kind of person, come visit me over at The Crafty Collaborative. Here you will find a group of us ladies reviewing and test driving all the fabulous recipes and DIYs we find on Pinterest. We’ll let you know if they’re worth diving into.

About Audrey

Audrey McClelland has been a digital influencer since 2005. She’s a mom of 5 and shares tips on her three favorite things: parenting, fashion and beauty. She’s also a Contemporary Romance Author.

Sign Up To The Ultimate Style Newsletter for Moms


ShopStyle “List” Of all Things I Like and Blog About



Comments are closed.